The 3 legged stool


Wisdom from Seth this week:

Three things you need if you want more customers

If you want to grow, you need new customers. And if you want new customers, you need three things:

1. A group of possible customers you can identify and reach.
2. A group with a problem they want to solve using your solution.
3. A group with the desire and ability to spend money to solve that problem.

You’d be amazed at how often new businesses or new ventures have none of these. The first one is critical, because if you don’t have permission, or knowledge, or word of mouth, you’re invisible.

The Zune didn’t have #2.

A service aimed at creating videos for bestselling authors doesn’t have #1.

And a counseling service helping people cut back on Big Mac consumption doesn’t have #3.

What Cha’ Drivin?


Folks are hanging on to their cars longer, but take a look at this prediction:

Japanese May Top Detroit 3 in February Sales

Sure, the auto industry is navigating new waters these days. But here’s an uncharted inlet we didn’t expect to find ourselves in — at least for a while.

In January, Japan’s automakers came within a smidgen of topping the Detroit 3 in U.S. monthly sales for the first time. And they may get the job done in February.

The Japanese sold 278,366 vehicles in January, just 1,165 fewer than General Motors, Ford and Chrysler.

“It is very likely that the Japanese automakers will outsell domestic automakers in February,” said analyst Jesse Toprak of Edmunds.com. “If the domestic automakers continue with their decision to cut fleet and rental sales into February, that may have the deciding impact.”

Last year the Detroit 3 held 47.5 percent of the U.S. market (sliding under 50 percent of annual sales for the first time), while the Japanese stood at 39.5 percent.

In January, the Detroit 3 advantage was considerably narrower: 42.6 percent to 42.4 percent.

But Toprak figures the Detroit 3 will hang on to their lead for the full year.

“It’s likely that they are not going to have this low of fleet and rental percentages for the rest of the year,” he said. “I think at the end of the year you’re going to see the domestics ahead of the Japanese, but not by very much.”

(Source: Automotive News, 02/16/09)

Grandpa is online….


50 year olds on Facebook?

Are Facebook And MySpace Becoming Uncool?
Advertising Age
Almost two years ago now, Mom and all her friends started signing up for Facebook. From there, colleagues, bosses, neighbors and others started creeping into the social networking site, once the exclusive playground of the Web’s young. For better or for worse, Advertising Age‘s Michael Learmonth says, social networking is no longer a youth phenomenon. In fact, he says, Facebook, with 52 million U.S. users and 170 million worldwide, is starting to look “like America.”

As of January 2009, more than 50% of Facebook’s users and 44% of MySpace’s users in the U.S. were over age 35, according to comScore’s estimates. The researcher also claims that the single biggest age demographic in the U.S. on both MySpace and Facebook is now between 35 and 44. And Facebook’s fastest growing demo is 55-plus.

To a certain extent, that has to be expected, as both Facebook and MySpace don’t have a lot of growing room left among younger demos. According to the Pew Internet and American Life project, 75% of online adults 18-24 already have a profile on a social network. Says Learmonth: “Generally, somewhere between growth and ubiquity is when uncool usually starts to set in.” College kids are usually a great barometer for what’s cool. According to Anderson Analytics, Facebook is still the No. 1 Web site on college campuses. MySpace, however, has fallen from second last year to No. 4 this year. – Read the whole story…

Marketing Wrap-Up


From the Thinking Blog:

Dusty Archives – February 2009 Edition

Posted: 20 Feb 2009 07:04 AM PST

From time to time we sort through the archives of THINKing to resurrect gems that you may have missed. Here are a few that we recommend.

It’s The Relationship, Stupid – I don’t care how you slice it, when it comes down to fundamentals, business is all about relationships. Ignore this truth at your own peril.

What Customers Want – Here’s the truth: Your customers don’t know what they want. And to assume otherwise is folly. When you begin relying totally on customers to be your product development department, you are asking for serious trouble.

Patience? No, Let’s Kill Something – There’s the old joke about the two buzzards sitting in a tree overlooking a highway. One responds to the other, “Be patient? I’m hungry. Let’s kill something.” Just like that buzzard, it is not in the nature of most marketers to be patient for business to grow.

Great Employees = Happy Customers – Companies spend millions of dollars each year identifying their brand, and then communicating their brand promise through various media. Employees are the primary “media” in the majority of brand contacts. Raise your hand if you think a majority of your employees understand your brand promise well enough to live it and articulate it clearly.

Better than Cold Calls


What’s better than making cold calls? Check out this advice from Steve Clark:

Sometimes it’s difficult to ask for referrals, whether as the sales person you don’t feel comfortable, you don’t like putting the pressure on to get referrals, maybe you haven’t worked with the person long enough to establish the relationship of being “referable”, or the customer/client may blow you off telling you “if I know of anyone, I’ll let them know about you”. Either way, you walk out without any names.

One of the best and easiest prospecting ideas is the opposite of the referral or the reverse referral. When you want to solicit similar businesses, for example, hardware stores or computer stores in the same vicinity of the customer you already have, this tip will apply.

Rip out the yellow pages for the type of business that you want to solicit in the same vicinity of your customer. If you are in a hardware store, show the hardware store yellow pages to your customer, which most likely would be the owner if this instance, and ask him which hardware store owners that you shouldn’t call on, either because they’re not as nice as you are. they’re difficult to work with, they have no money, they’re not progressive thinkers enough to expand their business, whatever the reason.

Give him a big black magic marker and ask him to cross off the names of the businesses that you shouldn’t call on. As he’s crossing off names, ask him to mark the names of the people you don’t know. Now there should be only a few unmarked names left. Discuss these remaining names with him and ask questions about the people’s personality, etc. At the end of your fact finding, ask your customer if you could use their name as you call on the remaining list. For the most hesitant referral, this normally works. Especially if you use the magic words, “I’d like to ask you for your help”

Friday Night Marketing News

Clickables from Mediapost:

Restaurants
by Karlene Lukovitz
Brands could benefit from more compelling Facebook pages, perhaps incorporating surveys, polling and a restaurant locator, Vitrue’s Reggie Bradford says. Providing franchisees with the tools to tap their online social circles to market local events is another opportunity, as is capturing event RSVPs to go back to individuals with coupons and other loyalty-building offers, he adds. … Read the whole story > >
Retail
by Karl Greenberg
“We like this program because it immediately spurs consumer spending on efficient appliances, since they get both a rebate and the efficiency savings,” says Jill Notini, VP communications and marketing at the Washington, D.C.-based AHAM, says the Energy Efficient Appliance Rebate Program will jump-start a market frozen by the housing crisis. … Read the whole story > >
Telecom
by Aaron Baar
“Compared with the cost of most of these devices, it’s the first time we’ve seen applications exceed the cost of the phones,” says Jeff Orr, ABI’s senior analyst for mobile content. The level of spending is even more considerable when taking into account that many of the applications come at a low cost–as low as 99 cents apiece in Apple’s iPhone App Store, … Read the whole story > >
Research
by Les Luchter
Companies plan to increase marketing efforts that highlight their social responsibility and what they are doing to minimize environmental impact, the study found. The study’s author also says there has been a significant shift in reasons for such marketing–what once was just good publicity has now become key to earning consumer trust. … Read the whole story > >
Retail
by Sarah Mahoney
Categories tied to housing fared the worst: Home and household goods, appliances, and lawn and garden. Margins declined, as the company cut prices to stay competitive, which were partially offset by lower expenses, including $94 million whacked from its advertising and display expenses in the fiscal year. … Read the whole story > >
Trends
by David Goetzl
A well-known researcher is projecting that the local ad market will continue to experience revenue dropoffs. More startling: the forecast covers the next five years, during which, some experts have predicted, the economy will presumably begin its turnaround. … Read the whole story > >

What’s for Dinner?


Check this out from CNN:

Fast-Food Chains Going After Sit-Down Diner Dollars

Fast-food chains are targeting cash-strapped patrons of casual-dining restaurants with premium products that are blurring the line between the two dining categories.

One chain boosting its high-end offerings is Burger King Holdings Corp. The No. 2 burger chain has installed a new broiler at over 60 percent of its stores in the U.S. and Canada that can cook foods like thicker burgers, ribs, kebabs and a host of other items that could give sit-down chains like DineEquity Inc.’s Applebee’s, Brinker International Inc. Chili’s or Ruby Tuesday Inc. a run for their money.

“The lines between a QSR and a casual diner, from a product standpoint, are starting to blur,” Goldman Sachs restaurant analyst Steven Kron said, referring to quick-service restaurants, jargon for fast-food chains.

In the same vein, Jack in the Box Inc. soon plans to roll out miniature sirloin burgers, which Chief Executive Linda Lang on Wednesday said are intended to rival the mini burgers sold at casual-dining restaurants.

While premium products can give a tasty boost to sales at fast-food restaurants and can help them stand out among their direct competitors, introducing them during an economic downturn may seem counterintuitive.

Consumers, strained with mounting job losses and dwindling wealth, are responding to low prices right now, with chains like Yum Brands Inc.’s KFC and Sonic Corp. trotting out national value menus for the first time. Higher-priced items could change the perception of the chains offering them, and send value-seeking customers elsewhere.

But Burger King is drawing a circle around the subset of the dining public that can no longer afford the casual-dining experience. With its latest product, a “Steakhouse XT” burger set to hit stores equipped with its new broiler next month, Burger King is hoping a thicker burger patty at a lower price could reel in some new customers.

For “someone who was having a premium burger at an Applebee’s or a Chili’s that’s paying $9 to $11 dollars and can come to Burger King for a Steakhouse Extra Thick burger and pay $5 to $6 dollars, that’s value to them,” Burger King Chief Executive John Chidsey said at a recent Deutsche Bank conference.

Premium products are nothing new for Burger King, McDonald’s Corp. and other fast-food chains, who have sold premium products alongside value items in so-called barbell or multi-tiered pricing strategies. While the value-menus get customers in the door, higher-priced items beef up bills.

To hold onto the value image, chains are adding lower-priced products as well as premium meals. Burger King, for instance, has also added a line of mini-burgers as it plans its premium burger.

McDonald’s, meanwhile, is experimenting with its own thicker burger. It has expanded tests of three varieties of an angus burger, a one-third pound burger patty on a higher-end bun, to 1,100 stores, and it’s pleased with results thus far, spokeswoman Danya Proud said.

McDonald’s has not set a time for a systemwide rollout, partly as it finishes installing premium-coffee capabilities at its stores, although some analysts suggested that the company pushed back the launch of the product due to the economy. Proud would not address that contention, although she said that McDonald’s sheer size, with nearly 14,000 U.S. locations, would let the company introduce the sandwich at a good value.

“We have to find a balance because we can’t alienate our core customers but we recognize the opportunity to bring in new customers with these items,” Proud said.

Fast-food chains may only have a temporary window to use premium products to woo diners who are trading down. Tom Forte, restaurant analyst with Telsey Advisory Group, said casual-dining chains got a boost in sales from last year’s stimulus checks. He said there may be some pent-up demand for a meal with waiter service and menus, and that the dining dollars could shift back fast once the economy rebounds..

A meal at a fast-food joint isn’t soon going to replicate the dining experience at a sit-down chain, which is one reason that operators in that sector are holding firm.

Susan Lintonsmith, chief marketing officer at Red Robin Gourmet Burgers Inc., said the company is not looking at fast-food places as a greater competitive threat any more than it did before the downturn. Instead, the company is playing up its own value message, which includes offering unlimited steak fries with each classic burger.

“We’re trying to make sure they know about our value proposition,” Lintonsmith said. “People are still looking for the experience and the quality of the food when they go out.”

For the time being, analysts think that fast-food chains will continue to have the edge.

“Given an increasingly difficult consumer environment, we question whether more consumers may be willing to sometimes sacrifice the full service experience with respect to atmosphere and service, particularly when (fast-food) competitors are responding with appealing and premium offerings to meet their needs,” Wachovia Capital Markets restaurant analyst Jeff Omohundro said in a recent note.

(Source: CNNMoney.com, 02/18/09)

Starbucks is using Social Media

Nearly every time I write something about Starbucks, the folks in Seattle find it and read it. Recently I featured a story from Content Marketing Today. Here’s an update:

Starbucks Listens. They Really Do Listen.

Posted: 27 Feb 2009 05:03 AM PST

starbucks barista What You Can Learn from Their Response to My Critical Commentary on Their New Instant Coffee Launch

Last week, I wrote a fairly skeptical post about the launch of Starbucks new instant coffee, Via Ready Brew. I suggested that it might suffer from a sad fate similar to that of ‘New’ Coke in 1984, in spite of the massive amount of research that both companies have conducted prior to the new product introductions.

In fact, I used the instant coffee launch to illustrate the power of the blogosphere for a mini case study with a class of PR strategy students from Florida Gulf Coast University. As a guest lecturer, I spoke to the class about content marketing and the growing importance of social media components such as business blogging. My Starbucks article and the company’s good-natured and gracious response perfectly illustrated the importance of monitoring and responding positively to the blogosphere.

In preparation for the class, I did a search on Starbucks and instant coffee on Google. Up came stories primarily from bloggers not from the mainstream media. Amazingly, if you search for ‘Starbucks instant coffee’ and ‘New Coke’, you actually pull up the article that I wrote.

Just as I was about to finalize and e-mail my presentation to the professor, I was surprised to receive a very gracious and good-humored response from Starbucks’ own Matthew Guiste, whose team is in charge of their social media efforts.

Here’s the comment that Matthew made to my post:

Thanks for the thoughtful commentary. I don’t know if it was a bazillion, but we did do a lot of research before this move, for sure. We think there’s a great opportunity in the market, one that tastes great and is 100% natural. As coffee-lover, I have a number of uses already in mind–visiting my father who lives in the country, to send to a friend of mine who’s office has bad coffee, and for mornings when I’m in a hurry. For reasons like that I personally can’t wait to get more than just my sample versions.

Did you get a chance to order a free sample?

Matthew’s comment was completely positive. Even better, he turned it into an opportunity to possibly persuade me of the error of my ways and encourage me that the new product would be a good thing.

Clearly, Starbucks has set up listening posts on the Internet so that it can monitor what people are saying about the company, its activities, and its products. When team members like Matthew respond to what they hear, they seek not to confront but to engage bloggers like me. That’s both positive and powerful in reinforcing the Starbucks image as good guys with great products.

Why you should emulate the Starbucks listening and response methodology

Today, it is both easy and free to monitor what others are saying about you, your products, your industry, and related issues on the Internet. With tools like Google Alerts and TweetGrid and TweetDeck for Twitter, you can monitor those activities in real time. Whenever appropriate, you can respond promptly–and positively–to what you hear. This makes for a wonderful way to engage both your customers and prospects as well as thought leaders on the web.

I may still be skeptical about instant coffee from Starbucks, but I sure admire their constructive use of social media to monitor and to engage folks who are taking an interest in the company. And, I do love their coffee.

Adapting Your Brand


What if you have a good brand name, but other factors force you to be creative with your marketing and advertising?

You adapt as explained in this story from the Hartford Courant:

WHAT’S IN A NAME?

Brands Adjust Marketing Strategies For Recession Mind-Set

By ANNE M. HAMILTON

Special to The Courant

February 22, 2009

With layoffs on the rise and stock markets headed down, we know that buyers are spending less. What that means for brand loyalty is a crucial question that’s still unfolding for purveyors of consumer goods and services.

Will shoppers stick to their old habits and remain loyal to their favorite brand items, such as a Starbucks latte or jeans from the Gap?

Or will they carpool to a dollar store to snap up store-brand cookies and purchase “pre-worn” clothes from Goodwill?

“It’s not an easy question,” said Akshay Rao, director of the Institute for Research in Marketing at the Carlson School of Management at the University of Minnesota. “People become more price-conscious, but will trade down only so much at a time.”

If people are used to eating out twice a month, for example, they will switch first to buying food at an upscale grocery. “It’s not steak to meatloaf overnight,” Rao said.

The demand for — and purchase of — expensive treats, such as a Starbucks grande and a $25 lipstick, will probably remain constant. “Will people purchase indulgences more because life is bleak?” Rao asked. “That’s the theory.”

One thing is clear: In every segment of the economy, manufacturers and marketers are scrambling to do whatever they can to retain brand loyalty, even as they face pressure to cut costs. Some are tweaking their sales pitch.

The Stanley Works, for example, has cut back on advertising and announced last year that it was eliminating 10 percent of its workforce as the new Britain-based toolmaker sees drops in the number of items it sells. But Stanley continues to sponsor events such as NASCAR races and promote new products, including the FuBar, a heavy-duty crowbar.

Stanley expects to see more do-it-yourself projects during the economic slowdown, which will lead to more sales.

“People are not hiring a professional. They are doing the job themselves,” said Scott Bannell, vice president of corporate brand management. “They have more time on their hands, more moonlighting.”

He said the company’s recessionary strategy is to continue to keep its brand visible to the public.

Taking advantage of trends is a key strategy across the board.

Quaker Oats? It’s always been healthy, but there’s a new pitch, said Andrew Razeghi, a lecturer in marketing at the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern: “It’s a cheaper form of protein.”

“A1 Sauce? Use it for hamburgers,” Razeghi said.

To attract or hold customers, banking giant Wachovia, now part of Wells Fargo, is hawking its Way2Save debit card, which automatically transfers $1 from checking to savings each time the debit card is used. In addition, it pays a 5 percent bonus on the amount saved, plus 5 percent annual interest.

You Only Live Once

Hartford resident Tanisha Nixon, a nurse’s aide who earns $17 an hour, said she’s staying loyal to national brands despite the economic kerfuffle. She buys her clothes at Lane Bryant and fills her shopping cart at the Stop & Shop in Bloomfield with name brands: Nabisco, Betty Crocker, General Mills. On a recent visit, the only private-label items in her basket were a can of corn and some ground pepper.

“You only live once,” Nixon said, and besides, her children, ages 10 and 12, refuse to eat store brand staples and turn up their noses at supermarket pizza.

If she’s running short on cash, she works weekend double shifts at premium pay. She relies on her boyfriend to bring home takeout meals or meat, but says he’s a different type of shopper. “He goes by cheapest. I go by quality,” she said.

Marketers, aware of sentiments such as Nixon’s, worry not just about current sales, but also about long-term loyalty. Customers who get used to cheaper goods or discount stores may not return to their former buying habits in better times.

“If you discount too much, it emphasizes to consumers that my clothes weren’t different from anyone else’s. Price competition undermines brand loyalty,” said Ravi Dhar, director of the Yale Center for Customer Insight at the Yale School of Management.

So traditional retailers are trying to walk a fine line between lowering their prices enough to stay solvent and retain their price-conscious patrons, and offering something extra, such as durability, value or service.

They may try “bundling,” or disguising discounts by selling multiple items at a slightly lower price, or trying to create an emotional attachment with their buyers, such as reviving Travelers’ umbrella logo, or emphasizing the traditional “You’re in good hands with Allstate” slogan, said Bill Field, president of Mintz & Hoke, an advertising and public relations company in Avon.

Sometimes, when a manufacturer produces higher- and lower-priced versions of the same product, buyers will stay with the company, but trade down. Instead of buying Pampers, made by Procter & Gamble, they might try Luvs, which P&G also makes. Or they will shop at Ann Taylor Loft instead of the main store.

Unique Goods

Many sellers play directly into the recession with pitches and special offers. Hyundai has raised the ante on that strategy. The Korean automaker is offering to take back your car and let you walk away if you lose your job within a year, even if you owe as much as $7,500 more than the car is worth.

“It’s clever. It takes into account what customers are worried about,” said Dhar, at Yale. “Hyundai really understands.”

Some products don’t seem to have any competitors, and their manufacturers have not been cutting prices. Tech goods, such as iPhones and iPods, appear to be unique. With iPods, “people want just an iPod,” Dhar said. “They have created a differentiated product.”

In the same way, some specialty stores seem to have a lock on consumer loyalty. The surge in popularity of organically grown food means that some customers will continue to pay premium prices for produce, meat and fish at a premium store such as Whole Foods, even though more and more big-box supermarkets are carrying more natural and organic offerings.

Liz Filloramo of Manchester is a Whole Foods devotee, even though she knows its prices are higher than those of standard supermarkets. “There are no hormones or pesticides. I’d rather pay a little more,” she said.

She relies on the chain’s produce, meats and fish and the brands she’s familiar with, even the organic pet foods. “I’m basically loyal. I know they are good.”

“Traditionally,” said Field, at Mintz & Hoke, “the best brands hold their value, even in the case of a recession.”

Talk to ME!


From a recent email:

Daily Sales Tip: Personalize Your Message

Think of all the ways that you communicate with your customers. From face-to-face meetings, to email, to direct marketing material, look for opportunities where you can include the customer’s name in your message.

Newsletters, estimates and direct-mail pieces are all good places to start. However, you must exercise good judgment!

First, find out whether they’re more comfortable with being referred to on a first-name basis. Second (and this is really important), don’t overuse their name, otherwise you’ll sound corny and even more impersonal than a form letter.

Source: Colleen Francis, president and founder of Engage Selling Solutions (www.engageselling.com, 2009)